10 Best Shops for Apple Pie in Nebraska

You can eat it a la mode, adorned with caramel, topped with whipped cream. Some prefer to wash it down with a glass of cold milk while others enjoy it with some dark roast coffee. Apple pie is an American staple eaten year-round. And these shops in Nebraska get it just right. 

Arbor Day Farm, Nebraska City, NE

Don’t only enjoy some pie at Arbor Day Farm, but also explore the 260 acres of the venue. There’s a 50-foot-tall treehouse to climb, miles of forested trails, the Arbor Lodge State Historical Park, and of course the gift shop to buy sweet treats at.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by veralynnpetersen (@veralynnpetersen) on

The Village Piemaker, Eustis, NE

Courtesy of its website, the Village Piemaker claims “pie brings people together.” That’s the goal at the Piemaker. With handcrafted pies in small batches, the restaurant bakes all of its pies with quality fillings—never anything from a can. Purchase pies to bring home and bake in your own oven—smells included. 

Grand Central Apple Market, Kearney, NE

While its name may be deceiving, its pies definitely aren’t. Grand Central Apple Market sells various groceries—not just apples. But in addition to the groceries sold, there are also fresh-baked pies, cakes, rolls, pastries and breads available. Emphasis on pies! 

Drifter Cookshack, Crawford, NE

Found on High Plains Homestead, Drifter Cookshack is a small eatery that boasts “good old-fashioned cooking with homemade pies.” The pies range from classic apple to cherry, with crimped edges and fruit oozing through the crust. Make a weekend of it and stay at the Homestead; eat all the pie that you can.

The Green Apple Cafe, Cozad, NE

The Green Apple Cafe offers a little slice of home. In a retro-looking cafe dining area, enjoy a homemade pie from family recipes. Bask in the ambiance of freshly brewed coffee, baking apple pies, and friendly customer service. It’s one of those places you stop for a slice and end up going home with the whole dang thing. 

Farm House Cafe and Bakery, Omaha, NE

They have baked pies, cream pies, and fresh fruit pies. Choose from apple, cherry, blueberry, peach, rhubarb, mincemeat, pecan, custard, lemon meringue, lemon silk, turtle fudge, fresh strawberry, fresh raspberry, and more. Need we go on?

Stauffer’s Cafe & Pie Shoppe, Lincoln, NE

Never been much of a baker? Place an order at Stauffer’s for a holiday pie. Whether it be apple for Christmas or a berry pie for the new year, choose from more than 50 different flavors to satisfy the family. Stop ragging on yourself for being a poor baker. Treat the family to a sweet pie from Stauffer’s.

Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop, Omaha, NE

According to its website, Sweet Magnolias is a “boutique bakery specializing in perfectly crafted, melt-in-your-mouth confections.” Bring a friend to enjoy a sweet treat at the cafe or check out the savory section of the menu. Magnolias offers slices of pies along with other delectable pastries.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop (@sweetmagnoliasbakeshop) on

Farmer’s Daughter Cafe, Grand Island, NE

Located on homey Walnut Street, the Farmer’s Daughter Cafe offers traditional diner food and with that comes traditional diner desserts. The cafe has a menu filled with homestyle cooking and baking. Reviews on its Facebook page state it has some of the “best food in town.”

The HUB, Burwell, NE

A unique location in Nebraska, the HUB is actually a mixture of a retail store, a coffee shop, and a soda fountain. Browse the aisles with pie in hand or coffee to go. It was originally built in 1906 as a general store but has expanded to offer pies and pastry treats as well as non-alcoholic beverages.

Nebraska Search
Find Pie Places Near You
Select a Nebraska town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Arthur County
Banner County
Box Butte County
Garfield County
Hayes County
Hooker County
Logan County
Loup County
Mcpherson County
Nance County
Rock County
Sioux County
Stanton County
Wheeler County